In challenging economic times, the traditional approach for enterprises is often to cut costs to improve financial performance. However, the key to sustainable success lies not in cost reduction alone but in the continuous improvement of Value Return (VR) per unit of cost incurred. This article explores the concept of VR and its significance in reshaping financial strategies.
The Essence of Value Return:
VR is the ratio of the value delivered to customers to the cost incurred by the company. It measures how efficiently a company uses its resources to create value for its customers. A high VR indicates that the company is spending wisely and generating more value per unit of cost. A low VR means that the company is wasting resources and creating less value per unit of cost.
Customer-Centric Spending:
One way to increase VR is to adopt a customer-centric approach to spending. Cost spenders should evaluate whether each rupee spent contributes to the company's VR. Assessing expenditures from the customer's perspective ensures a focus on value creation. For example, investing in product innovation, quality improvement, or customer service can enhance VR by increasing customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Trustees of Customers' Money:
Another way to increase VR is to act as trustees of customers' money. Suppliers, as trustees of customers' money, must ensure that added costs translate into real value for customers. Value is only created when customers willingly return the perceived value for the money spent. For example, charging a premium price for a product or service can be justified only if it delivers superior value to customers.
Avoiding Losses and Global Competition:
A low VR can have serious consequences for a company's financial performance and competitiveness. Companies that build costs without delivering customer value face losses and struggle in the global market. Conscious cost management ensures competitiveness in a free economy. For example, reducing unnecessary costs, eliminating waste, or outsourcing non-core activities can improve VR by lowering costs without compromising value.
In today's competitive and dynamic business environment, cost-cutting is often seen as a necessary and effective strategy to improve profitability and efficiency. However, cost-cutting alone may not be enough to achieve the desired results. In fact, it may even backfire and harm the business in the long run. That is why we need to adopt a new paradigm of maximizing returns, which we call Value Return (VR).
What is VR and How to Practice It?
VR is a concept that goes beyond the traditional cost vs. benefit analysis. Instead of focusing on reducing costs, VR focuses on increasing the value of the business by exploring opportunities to improve VR by incurring costs elsewhere. For example, instead of cutting advertisement expenses, VR suggests that we may increase our sales and revenue by spending more on effective and targeted ads. Similarly, instead of offering discounts to attract customers, VR recommends that we may enhance customer loyalty and satisfaction by offering free gifts or other incentives.
VR is not a one-size-fits-all approach. It requires a thorough understanding of the business context, the customer needs, the market trends, and the competitive landscape. It also requires creativity and innovation to identify and implement the best solutions for each situation. VR is not a static concept either. It evolves with time and changes with the business environment. Therefore, VR requires constant monitoring and evaluation to ensure its effectiveness and efficiency.
How to Avoid Increasing Per Unit Cost with VR?
One of the main objectives of VR is to reduce the per-unit cost of the business. Per-unit cost is the total cost incurred by the business divided by the number of units sold or produced. Reducing per-unit cost means increasing the profit margin and improving the competitiveness of the business.
However, traditional cost-cutting may not always reduce per-unit cost. In some cases, it may even increase it. For example, if we reduce the quality of our packing materials to save costs, we may end up losing customers who are dissatisfied with our products or services. This will result in lower sales and higher per-unit cost.
To avoid this pitfall, VR advocates spending more on quality packing materials that can enhance the appeal and value of our products or services. This will result in higher sales and lower per-unit cost. A case study from a consumer goods company illustrates this point.
Case Study: Glossy vs. Ordinary Packing
The company was selling a range of personal care products in ordinary packing materials. The management decided to cut costs by switching to cheaper and lower quality packing materials. However, this decision proved to be counterproductive. The customers perceived the products as inferior and less reliable due to the poor packing quality. The sales dropped significantly and the per-unit cost increased.
The company realized its mistake and reverted to its original packing materials. However, this time, it decided to upgrade them to glossy and attractive packing materials that reflected the quality and value of its products. The customers responded positively to this change and perceived the products as superior and more trustworthy. The sales increased significantly and the per-unit cost decreased.
How to Implement VR: Mass Consultancy Services
VR can be applied to any type of business, regardless of its size, nature, or industry. However, some businesses may face more challenges than others in implementing VR due to their specific characteristics or constraints. For example, a consultancy firm may have high marketing overheads and underutilization of managerial resources that affect its VR.
To overcome these challenges, the firm can adopt a strategy called "Mass Consultancy Services." This strategy involves creating standardized consultancy products that can be accessed by a wide range of enterprises through online platforms or other channels. These products are designed to address common business problems or opportunities that are relevant to many enterprises across different sectors or regions.
Benefits
By adopting this strategy, the firm can achieve several benefits:
How to Compute VR and What is the Ideal VR?
VR can be measured using a simple mathematical formula:
VR for a Period = Σ X ÷ Σ Y
Where,
Σ X = Aggregate Revenue for the Period
Σ Y = Aggregate Cost Component for the Period
The formula can be applied to any period of time, such as a month, a quarter, or a year. The formula can also be applied to any cost component, such as advertisement expenses, packing materials costs, or consultancy fees.
Normative or Ideal VR:
VR = 1 + Z, where Z = ROI in absolute Rupees ÷ Budgeted Total costs. Ideal VR is 1.2, indicating a positive return after covering costs.
The formula can help us evaluate our current VR and compare it with our desired or ideal
The Way Forward with VR
Beyond Traditional Approaches
Cost cutting has been a common practice among businesses for decades, especially during times of economic uncertainty. However, this approach has proven to be ineffective and even detrimental in the long run, as it often leads to reduced quality, lower customer satisfaction, and diminished innovation. Moreover, cost cutting can trigger a vicious cycle of recession, as lower spending reduces demand and income for other businesses.
In contrast, a new concept called Value Return (VR) offers a more sustainable and profitable way of managing costs. VR is based on the idea that costs are not simply expenses to be minimized, but investments that can generate value returns if managed wisely. VR challenges the traditional thinking of cost cutting, and encourages a proactive approach that focuses on making costs fully effective rather than simply downsizing them.
Economic Impact
The benefits of VR are manifold. First, VR promotes economic growth by encouraging businesses to think creatively about how to optimize their cost-effectiveness. Rather than slashing costs indiscriminately, businesses can identify and leverage the areas where they can create the most value for their customers,stakeholders, and society. This way, they can increase their revenue, market share, and reputation, while also contributing to the overall economic well-being.
Second, VR avoids the negative consequences of cost cutting, such as compromising quality, losing customers, and stifling innovation. By adopting a value-centric mindset, businesses can maintain or even improve their standards of excellence, retain or attract loyal customers, and foster a culture of innovation and learning. These factors are essential for achieving long-term success and competitiveness in a dynamic and uncertain market environment.
Implementation Challenges
However, VR is not without its challenges. One of the main challenges is to overcome the ingrained habit of cost cutting that many businesses have developed over the years. VR requires a paradigm shift in the way businesses think about and manage their costs. It also requires a clear understanding of the difference between "Dead Costs" and potential areas for cost-effectiveness. Dead Costs are those that do not generate any value returns, and should be eliminated or minimized as much as possible. Potential areas for cost-effectiveness are those that can generate value returns if managed properly, and should be optimized or enhanced as much as possible.
Another challenge is to avoid stretching VR beyond its boundaries. VR is not a magic bullet that can solve all the problems of a business. It is not a license to spend recklessly or irresponsibly. It is not a substitute for sound financial management or strategic planning. VR is a concept that can help businesses make better decisions about their costs, but it should be applied with caution and common sense.
Practical Tool for Downturns
Finally, VR is a practical tool that can help businesses cope with economic downturns more effectively. In times of crisis, many businesses resort to cost cutting as a knee-jerk reaction, hoping to survive the storm. However, this strategy can backfire and worsen the situation. Instead of cutting costs blindly, businesses should adopt the VR concept and look for ways to maximize their value returns. By doing so, they can not only survive the downturns, but also emerge stronger and more resilient.
In conclusion, the Value Return concept emerges as a powerful strategy for enterprises looking to navigate economic challenges effectively. By prioritizing value creation over cost-cutting, businesses can thrive in a competitive and dynamic market environment.
© 2024 Business Consultant & Law Firm - Legacy Partners. All Rights Reserved.
Designed by Nuewelle Digital Solutions LLP
Legacy Partners
We typically reply in a few minutes
